For the Love of the Drive - ID# 128

Deerfield
Documentary
Entry Description

A local vintage car club brings together retirees from around the region. While they may be tinkering with classic British sports cars, more importantly they are forming irreplaceable human bonds to support one another as senior citizens.

Copyright Info

Recent Teacher Comments

  • 4/3 9:03 pm - KEEPERS: Really cool documentary about a specific niche within the car club/antique car club community. I like that you found something specific within this culture to explore. Really nice production value overall. Your interview set ups were all well done with good lighting and specific consideration given to the backgrounds. The broll was well shot and varied. Your edit was well paced and the music was well chosen. IMPROVEMENTS: I wish you could have spent more time with your interview subjects and perhaps this wasn't possible due to time constraints or what have you. But your next step as a documentarian is to spend time with your interviewees at a car show and film them "in the wild" interacting with car enthusiasts and using some of that nat sound footage to add more nuance and depth to the story. Make that your next challenge for your next documentary. Overall, well done!
  • 3/4 9:49 am - What Worked Well: ✅ High-Energy Opening – The combination of music and dynamic car shots immediately engages the audience. ✅ Creative B-Roll & Composition – You avoided overusing wide shots and instead incorporated diverse camera angles, making the visuals more dynamic. ✅ Excellent Interview with Brian – Well-lit, great composition, and the car in the background added to the scene’s authenticity. ✅ Effective Use of Stock Photos – Including historical images helped enhance the story and connect with the older audience. ✅ Strong Personal Storytelling – The documentary successfully highlights the club’s unique culture in a way that feels personal and engaging. Areas for Improvement: Lighting for B-Roll – Don’t hesitate to bring extra lighting when capturing b-roll. Thoughtful lighting can enhance the depth, reflections, and details of the cars, making them stand out even more. Continue Experimenting with Camera Movements – While the variety of angles was strong, pushing creative movements further (e.g., slow tracking shots, close-up details, or low angles) could highlight the uniqueness of the cars even more. This is a fantastic piece that effectively captures the spirit of the car group. Keep pushing your creativity with lighting and movement to make future projects even more visually striking!
  • 2/24 1:59 pm - STORY: The interviews, and the way you cut them up, really showed how these guys have a passion for this interest and industry. I’m guessing this could be a full length feature documentary, so it's impressive that you were able to convey this story within the very short time restrictions of the MMEA. PRODUCTION: Beautiful interview set ups, framing, and lighting. You clearly had cooperative interviewees and a great location for the background. The sound from the interviews is also very clear. I’ve gone back to watch this twice because your b-roll is amazing and the story is compelling. You should be proud of this project, regardless of what happens in the MMEA Video Festival. This is a superb documentary. Literally like network quality.
Judge 1

Positives: Great job showcasing everyone's stories about how they got involved in the MG Club. Interview lighting and backdrops were well-thought out and appropriate to the story. Excellent ending. Overall, very well done.

Improvements: Some of the interviews segments didn't flow well together - I think some breathing room would have been beneficial. Interviewee introductions other than lower thirds would have been nice.

Judge 2

Positives: Really good composition with the cars and/or garages in the shot during the interview. Good choice of upbeat music. Great that you told the story of their love of cars through their personal history. Loved that you had a message about the future and the past when it comes to loving cars! Nice variety of B Roll. Camera movement, variety, well composed, all added to the story.

Improvements: Some more background music would have been a plus.

Judge 3

Positives: Fantastic edit. Very strong and competent work in regard to story construction. I like that you left pockets of breathing time throughout where the music came up in the mix and you should imagery/broll that leads into the next part of the story. Great example of how you can structure a short story like this and use the power of editing to make a stronger story. Great camera work throughout. Your broll is well exposed and framed. I felt like I was there at the car show! Also good work finding the archive photos. Awesome job! Keep it up.

Improvements: You had a great intro and well structured story, however I felt the ending could have been reworked. I felt like it ended a bit abruptly if it was not intentional. I think it would have been great to hear from some of the people attending the rally/showcase and see why they decided to go, to hear an outsiders perspective. I kept waiting for this to come in the film. Maybe that is not your intention though.

Judge 4

Positives:

Improvements:

Judge 5

Positives:

Improvements: