This is an excerpt from our coverage of one of the biggest games of the year. This clip features some amazing back-to-back plays that our crew captured. All announcer and crew positions are students, and all of our games are streamed live.
Positives: The graphics were great! Aesthetically pleasing and clear. The transition from live action to slo-mo replay into the free throw shots. Very smooth. Great use of graphic elements to enhance.
Improvements: Tighten high shots as teams enter half court. Careful cutting away during moves to the basket. Handheld a bit shaky at start.
Positives: Having multiple camera angles was great. I also appreciated the transition graphics for the instant replay so the viewer won't be confused.
Improvements: The camera work at the baseline seemed a bit unsteady. I know there is typically not a tripod being used in that situation, but it still seemed more unsteady than it should. Sitting and bracing yourself in a rolling chair is a trick you sometimes see used in broadcasts. The lower third graphic was a nice touch to share information on the scorer, but it felt a bit as though it were lacking content. I understand that budget and support staff may not allow for live stat updates, but a bit more information on the player might be nice.
Positives: I thought the talent did a very good job setting up the situation, working together, and showing emotion. This is a small clip, obviously, but from what I heard it was done well. The audio person also did a good job of riding the levels so it did not over-modulate when exciting events happened.
Improvements: The overall audio mix was low and did not sound the best, so definitely room for improvement there on set-up. On the missed 3 pointer, my advice would be not to switch to the low camera because it is jarring for the viewer. I understand because of the students/camera placement that you couldn't see everything, but if you high camera panned, you should still get enough. You then have the low camera available for your replay look. A lot of work went into the animated supers, but I think it was a bit too much. Also, since you went to replay, trying to squeeze the info in before the FT was tough. I think stats are more useful to the viewer than an animated picture.
Positives:
Improvements: