This film is about a boy who struggles to express his own femininity to his mom.
subscription to storyblocks(audioblocks).
Positives: Well done, showing the arc of the story rather than telling it... this film deserves a wider audience and a slightly longer narrative to show his struggles with himself. A young person's struggle with 'identity' and is nicely illustrated. I would encourage this filmmaker to expand this into a 12-15 minute short film. The subject matter would be welcomed in the festivals. Sound (music) is very purposeful and appropriate. Nicely accomplished in terms of the setting.
Improvements: A 360' view of the room showing his struggle between traditional expectations of 'boy' vs 'girl' would have been nice. That way we could instantly recognize the 'world' he lives in, the expectations placed on him and the fight to express his desires (narratively speaking and production design resolved). The boy's narration could have been accomplished in a more subdued manner; the 'interior voice' seems a little too 'outdoorsy.' The narration should be differentiated from his inner voice and his declaration to his Mom.
Positives: Simple, yet effective narrative. The use of close ups helped pull in the audience.
Improvements: The tone shift would have been more effective if the beginning was edited quicker and the felling was that of a carefree party. Then an abrupt tonal shift to panic when his mother knocks.
Positives: Strong message. You did a good job developing the conflict within the main character. You also created an emotional piece that will get some people to think.
Improvements: You spend about 40 seconds of the main character looking themselves. There were only three shots during that time. Consider shooting eight or nine shots for the this scene and dissolving from one shot to the next. Include some closeups after the mom call the main character to dinner. You can build some of the tension they are experiencing through editing with a variety of shots with varying compositions.
Positives:
Improvements: