A studio-based and highly visual meditation on a standard Starbucks delight; the Frappuccino. MUSIC Dayum https://freesound.org/people/loveless1017/sounds/455443/
Positives: Sound was excellent. I felt your mix was right for a commercial of this nature. Your shots seemed to work narratively.
Improvements: The shots were to long, which slowed the video down in a way that didn't mesh well with the mix. The pace was wrong for this commercial.
Positives: Love that this edit puts special focus on the transitions, and connecting one scene to the next in an artful way. It's not easy to do and this is a very good effort. Beautiful shot of cream blooming in coffee. Nice use of Foley sfx.
Improvements: The glasses with ice need some love with the lighting - they look a little 'low fi' The spot doesn't do anything to distinguish this as a Starbucks product vs. any other brand. You must have that in a commercial.
Positives: Shooting good tabletop/food footage is realy hard, and it's great to see someone giving it a go. Loved the shot of the cream mixing into the coffee, and the rotational camera moves and dolly moves were nice and smooth. Good sound work and some nice speed-changes in the edit to cary the pace.
Improvements: It's easy to nitpick tabletop - the extra drips from the bottle, the wrinkles in the bag, etc. This stuff is often cleaned up in post (that's my job!) Would have been nice to see a cleaner edge on the bottle for the endframe - your colors and composition are great there. If you could have shot some slo-mo, you could have added some dramatic slow-downs to the pours, though I realize you might have been limited by your equipment there.
Positives:
Improvements: